Your Next 100 DPC and Concierge Patients

Watch The Video:

What happens after you finally open the doors to your direct primary care or concierge practice, and the only thing waiting for you is 4 walls?

You did all the hard things. You bought the equipment, rented the space, launched the website, put together your membership offer, and probably did some marketing too. A few people signed up, most likely former coworkers, friends, and family, and you thought things were really cooking. Then day after day, it was just you and those 4 walls, wondering how on earth you were going to fill this practice.

Most physicians believe opening the practice is the real work, and it IS work; it’s hard, and I’m not discounting that for a second. The real work, though, is filling your practice so it becomes sustainable, so you can start this new adventure knowing you made the right decision and (let’s face it, this is a really big deal), so you can pay your bills consistently.

If you’ve been open for 2, 3, or 4 years and growth has gone from slow to stagnant, or you scraped your current membership together and you’re losing members almost as fast as you add them, keep reading. Chances are you’re missing at least one of the pieces below, and fixing it can change your practice growth in as little as 30 days. 

Patients are asking questions your website doesn’t answer

If you’ve been in direct primary care or concierge medicine for a while, you’ve probably noticed the public is starting to understand what you do a little better than they used to. But you may also not be aware that there is still a lot of misunderstanding around the industry. I recently met with someone who thought concierge medicine meant a doctor who comes to your door. Sometimes it does, but more often it’s medicine practiced in a clinic that gives patients a one-to-one relationship and a lot more attention.

Most education practices focus on what patients receive – this many visits a year, this many times with the physician, this price for one person, this price for two, this price for a family. What it rarely covers is the reasons someone would choose your practice in the first place. When people shop for care outside their insurance, they’re looking for a reason to pay the extra money, and if you can’t meet them where they are, you lose the opportunity before they ever walk through your door.

They’re quietly asking themselves questions like these:

  • What am I actually paying for? (If the answer is “another doctor, just faster,” that doesn’t cut it for an extra $100 or $200 a month, and I’ve seen pricing run as high as $400.)
  • Does this replace my insurance?
  • What do I get for what I’m paying, and what’s the difference between your price levels?
  • Why should I come to you instead of going to my primary doctor?
  • What happens in an emergency, or if I need a specialist or a hospital?
  • Is this really worth the cost?

I’ve looked at a lot of concierge practice websites, and most of them don’t answer even the simple ones. If you’re not answering these questions from the very beginning, it’s really not a mystery why your practice isn’t as full as you’d like it to be.

“We just need more leads” is usually the wrong first move

When I ask concierge and membership practices why they don’t have enough patients, the answer is almost always that they need more lead generation. So I ask who they’re trying to attract, and I usually get a dumbfounded look followed by, “Well, patients, obviously.”

That’s a little like throwing a straw into a haystack and yelling, “Come find me!” Every practice wants patients, including the ones down the street that don’t run a membership model, and those practices usually have corporations behind them spending millions of dollars on marketing. You will never outspend them, which means you have to get much clearer about who you serve and how you serve them.

What you’ve probably already tried

Before we get into why it hasn’t worked, let’s be honest about what you’ve likely done so far. Maybe you set up Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, or all of the above. Maybe you outsourced your posting overseas, or you’re doing it yourself, or you hired a kid to create content for you (no judgment). Maybe you’re running ads, relaunched your website, joined networking groups, sponsored community events, introduced yourself to the neighbors around your office, reached out to former colleagues and patients, started a YouTube channel, or hired an agency because you simply don’t have time to market on top of practicing medicine.

And if you’re like most physicians I talk with, you’re probably splitting time between the hospital, another practice, and your own, which leaves you stretched pretty thin.

If you’ve done any or all of that, you’re not alone. You may have decided that marketing just doesn’t work, that people won’t pay for this, or that the economy is the problem. Or, in my opinion, the worst conclusion of all, that you just need to do more. When you’re already stretched thin and things aren’t working, it’s time to slow down and step back.

5 reasons your marketing hasn’t worked yet

I say this on the show all the time, and I’ll keep saying it because it’s true – you were trained to heal people; your specialty is medicine, not marketing, and definitely not the strategy behind growing a practice. You’re doing the very best you can, and these are the gaps I see most often.

#1 You haven’t answered the foundational questions

Not everyone is going to be a fit for your practice. I know that makes people uncomfortable, especially when you need patients coming in, but the more comfortable you get with that statement, the faster you’ll grow. When you get clear, you cut through the noise and create a direct path for the right people to find you. These are the questions that matter most:

  • Who do you want to work with? And no, “anyone with a pulse” doesn’t count.
  • What are they struggling with right now? What are they running into with traditional healthcare, or with another provider, that has them looking for someone new? “You want to thrive in your life” is so generic; nobody knows what it means. I recently talked with a pelvic floor provider whose colleague focuses specifically on new mothers, and her business is thriving to the point that she has brought on 5 or 6 new clinicians to keep up. Answering these first 2 questions alone heads off so many of the “why am I paying extra for this?” objections.
  • Why you over Dr. Jones down the street? This usually isn’t about your credentials, which is where physicians want to go first. It’s about why you do what you do. I spoke with a physician whose passion is longevity, and he lights up talking about the research and about helping people not only live longer but enjoy those extra years. That attracts a very specific audience, but only if he talks about it. The things you don’t naturally share because they feel personal are often your biggest asset.
  • Why do they need to choose you now? This one almost never gets answered because it’s a marketing question, and it’s the one that keeps people from making a decision. For longevity, the answer can be as simple as “the earlier you start, the better your chances of a longer and better life.” Leave it unanswered, and it lingers in the mind of every potential patient.
  • What’s the quickest route to the result they want? I recommend 3 steps. You can’t diagnose everyone in 3 steps; I understand that, but our brains tend to tune out once a plan goes past 3, which is exactly why every action plan on my show has 3. Give people a simple roadmap, and they’ll remember it. Skip it, and they’ll decide it’s too hard, too complicated, or too expensive, and move right along.
  • What can they get from you that they can’t get anywhere else? Longer visits and quicker access aren’t enough anymore, because every new concierge practice says the same thing. On last week’s episode, I shared the story of an endocrinologist whose membership includes far more than his patients realize, and most of it gets mentioned exactly once.

#2 Your messaging is about you, not them

Most medical websites and social media talk about the physician, the office, and what’s offered. A med spa or functional medicine clinic might list 9,000 services, and every one of them is a solution. If I’m a new patient trying to figure out whether you’re right for me, I don’t see myself on your website. I don’t see my problems. I see a list of things that might help, and I don’t know enough about them to tell.

If you want to reach the people who want to work with you, write from their viewpoint, as though they’ve pulled up a chair and started telling you their life story. You have only a few seconds to get their attention, and the questions on their mind are very practical. Will I always see the same doctor? Can I really get in the same day? How long will I wait if I can’t? How involved will the doctor and staff actually be? Will I feel rushed? And maybe the most important one: is this going to be easier than what I’m dealing with now?

When your website is all services and credentials, you aren’t answering any of those, and people leave feeling like you don’t understand them.

#3 You’re trying to be everywhere

Every social channel, YouTube, a podcast, blog posts, networking events, LinkedIn outreach, and on and on. If you haven’t created clarity about who you help and how, it doesn’t matter where you show up, because nobody is paying attention when everyone else is doing the same thing. And your best friend liking your post at 2 in the morning while doomscrolling doesn’t count if that person never becomes a patient or sends one your way.

You’re better off choosing 1 or 2 places where your specific patients spend time, doing very intentional work there, and measuring it by how many people actually come into your practice. Not likes, not clicks, not shares. If you’re spending even $1,500 a month on Facebook ads and the phone isn’t ringing, you’re burning money. People expect relationships now, especially younger generations who largely tune out advertising and business-oriented posts.

#4 There’s no system to follow up

I see this all the time. Practices will run ads pointing to a random web page with no way of knowing whether anyone booked. A promotion goes out, and nobody opts in (maybe nobody wanted it). People guard their names and email addresses almost as closely as their Social Security number these days, so when someone does raise a hand, you need a plan to stay in front of them, many times over.

People also expect you to have your ducks in a row. Someone should answer the phone, or an instant follow-up should go out when nobody can. A form submission shouldn’t sit for 24 hours. Pricing and service questions should be answered online or within minutes. Scheduling, rescheduling, and canceling shouldn’t require talking to a person. If someone follows you from social media to your website and then can’t get an appointment, they’re gone, and you’ve already broken their trust. Build a smooth journey first, then decide how to drive people into it.

#5 You’re trying to be everything to everyone

The practices that go narrower succeed more, and they succeed faster. If you’re an endocrinologist focused on diabetes care, and maybe even more specifically on younger people with diabetes, that’s what you become known for. The same goes for families, longevity, or pelvic floor care for new mothers. It’s easier for people to decide for themselves whether you’re the right fit, and it’s much easier for them to refer you.

My favorite example is a pelvic floor specialist in my area who named her business The Coochie Doc. Cute name, and think about how easily people refer her. She’s made it obvious what she does and who she helps, and she gave everyone a name they can’t help repeating.

What practices that are filling up do differently

When I look at practices that are growing well, they have a few things in common, and you can emulate every one of them.

  • They’re clear about who they help and why they’re different.
  • They explain what their offer means, not just what it includes. The endocrinologist I mentioned includes a member portal with nutritionists and lifestyle support. One of his main audiences is people with diabetes, so the best way to describe that portal is “support for every step of your journey, not just medication,” because the goal is helping patients thrive so they don’t need medication for the rest of their lives if they don’t want it.
  • They’re easy to find. I recently came across a direct primary care office that shows up under “concierge medicine” but not “primary care.” If patients aren’t searching your term, you don’t show up, and “primary care” is a pretty big term to miss.
  • They’re easy to reach. Updated online profiles, someone (or something) answering the phone, and online booking. If people can’t book online, why make it so hard for them to work with you?
  • They build authority. Educational videos, speaking at events, showing up in the communities their patients belong to.
  • They build trust through reviews, and they respond to every one so people know they were heard.
  • They measure success by members, not followers. They aren’t necessarily outworking you. They’re consistent, and their tactics line up with their goals.

What this is costing your practice

Every day you sit in an empty clinic costs you rent, software subscriptions, insurance, and the rest of the list. The hidden costs show up when panic starts driving decisions: lowering your price, adding discounts, giving things away, hiring a new agency, adding staff before you’re ready, running more ads, or redesigning the website without any clarity about what needs to change.

Lowering your price is one of the last things I recommend, because the objection usually isn’t really about price. If you’re $20 a month more than a competitor and someone chooses them, chances are it wasn’t the $20. It was the lack of explanation for why you’re worth it.

Those rushed decisions cost money, time, and energy, but the cost nobody measures is your belief in what you’re building. Every choice that doesn’t line up with where you want to go chips away at the reasons you started: autonomy over your medicine, more time with your patients, getting back to what medicine means to you, and leaving behind the bureaucracy and paperwork. Let that sink in for a minute, because when you’re making rash decisions to get anyone in the door, you give away a little of that every single time.

Your 3-Step Action Plan:

You don’t have to fix the entire system at once, but you can take action in the right direction.

Define your best members.

Who are you working with? How does your model support them? What are they struggling with right now, and how does your offer solve it? Who can afford your membership? What do they do for a living, where do they spend time, who are their friends, and do those friends already belong to a concierge practice?

Then pull it into 1 sentence: “Our best members are ___ who are frustrated by ___ and want ___.”

For example: “Our best first members are new mothers who want to recover from childbirth so they can feel vibrant and sexy again.” Yours will look different, but that’s the shape.

Rewrite your offer from the patient's point of view.

Not a laundry list. (I’m looking at you, med spa menus with supplements, skincare, Botox, red light therapy, IV treatments, and on down the line.)

Make it so painfully clear who you work with that a third grader could tell me, not because your patients aren’t smart, but because you have seconds to let them know they’re in the right place.

Then tell them what your offer means for their lifestyle, their future, and their stress level.

To test it, ask someone outside medicine to look at your website for 7 seconds, close the screen, and tell you what you do. Most clinic websites read as though someone in medicine wrote them, and this test shows it fast.

Pick 2 acquisition channels for 30 days.

Choose 1 that’s outside your control, like referral relationships, being found on Google, partnerships with people who serve the same audience in a different way, or your existing patient network. Choose 1 that builds your authority, like educational workshops, speaking, guesting on podcasts, community partnerships, or email. Focusing on 2 for 30 days keeps you from getting overwhelmed, lets you iron out how you talk about yourself, and gives you real data. Most of the time you don’t need more tactics. You need enough data to know which ones are working so you can go all in or pivot.

Your next 100 members almost certainly won’t come from a magical marketing tactic. Spend $5,000 a month on ads aimed at everyone, and you might get 1 or 2 random people, and you’ll likely lose them along the way anyway.

When you can’t answer these questions yet

If you’re reading this and thinking, “I have no idea, we’ve tried everything, and I don’t have answers to any of these questions,” that’s exactly why physicians book a Growth Review Call with me. It isn’t a you’re-doing-it-wrong session. We look at what you’re doing, what’s working, and what may have worked before you swept it under the rug because it wasn’t a big enough bang, and you leave with an action plan for where to focus over the next 30 days, no matter what stage your practice is in.

Prefer to listen? Hear the full episode of The Profit Loop here.

Find Out Where Your Practice Growth Is Stuck

If you don’t have an outside perspective on your practice, that is exactly what I provide during a free 20-minute Growth Review. Together, we will identify your practice’s biggest growth challenge so you know where to focus your energy to eliminate it.

Do the Math for Your Practice

Download the free worksheet that walks you through exactly how to find these numbers, calculate your referral completion rate, and see the revenue impact specific to your practice.  The free worksheet takes about five minutes to complete. 

src="https://docs.alisaconner.com/widget/form/NejqE3u6DmOmdmmBYYOG" style="width:100%;height:100%;border:none;border-radius:3px" id="inline-NejqE3u6DmOmdmmBYYOG" data-layout="{'id':'INLINE'}" data-trigger-type="alwaysShow" data-trigger-value="" data-activation-type="alwaysActivated" data-activation-value="" data-deactivation-type="neverDeactivate" data-deactivation-value="" data-form-name="Referral Loss Calculator" data-height="670" data-layout-iframe-id="inline-NejqE3u6DmOmdmmBYYOG" data-form-id="NejqE3u6DmOmdmmBYYOG" title="Referral Loss Calculator" >

About the Author

Alisa Conner is a Strategic Growth Advisor who helps independent medical practices and professional service organizations find where their growth is stuck and empower their teams to run efficiently, so owners can focus on serving the people they want to serve. She hosts The Profit Loop, a weekly podcast and YouTube series, and is based in Boulder, Colorado.

Love this episode?  We would love a Review! Don’t forget to subscribe so you don’t miss any episodes!

Frequently Asked Questions

What's the difference between concierge medicine and direct primary care?

Both offer a closer relationship with your physician for a recurring fee. Concierge practices often still bill insurance for visits and charge a membership fee on top, while direct primary care practices typically don’t bill insurance for primary care and charge a flat monthly fee that covers most primary care services.

Does a concierge or DPC membership replace health insurance?

No. A membership covers primary care, but you still need coverage for emergencies, specialists, hospital stays, and other care outside the practice. Starting in 2026, people with HSA-eligible health plans can use their health savings account for direct primary care fees, up to $150 a month for an individual and $300 a month for a family.

Should I lower my membership fee to attract more patients?

Usually not. When someone hesitates over price, the real issue is most often that they don’t understand what the membership means for them. Explaining your offer from the patient’s point of view often does more than a discount.

How many marketing channels should a new DPC or concierge practice use?

Start with 2 for 30 days: 1 outside your control, such as referrals or Google, and 1 that builds your authority, such as workshops or podcasts. Measure them by how many people become members, then go all in or pivot.

What should a concierge practice website say first?

Who you help and what they’re struggling with, clearly enough that a new visitor knows within seconds they’re in the right place. Services and credentials can come after that.